TaxTidy vs Expensify: 2026 Comparison
Expensify is built around a workflow most solo businesses never run — an employee submits an expense, a manager approves it, the company reimburses it — and it runs that workflow well. Its free Submit plan now includes unlimited receipt scanning for an individual, which makes it a perfectly reasonable receipt vault. TaxTidy is built for the person who has nobody to submit to. Every receipt you photograph is read, categorised and placed on the Schedule C line it belongs to, and your Audit Readiness Score tells you which ones still lack proof. At the end of your year there is no approver waiting, only a return.
What you get with TaxTidy
- Every expense is placed on the Schedule C line it belongs to, so what you build across the year is the return itself rather than a stack of reports nobody will approve.
- Your Audit Readiness Score is the answer to the question a solo filer actually loses sleep over: which of these could I prove? It names the expenses with no image, no category, no date, no vendor.
- Shoebox Mode clears a backlog in one sitting. Select the whole camera roll and TaxTidy works through it card by card, which is the difference between filing a year of receipts and abandoning them.
- On Pro and above, the PDF report carries the full-size receipt image beside each expense, grouped by Schedule C line — a document built for an accountant or an auditor, not for a manager.
- Fin answers against your own numbers: what you spent with a vendor, whether something counts, how the quarter looks. Three questions a day on the free plan, more on Pro and CPA.
- Setup is three questions — business name, business type, tax year — and then you are scanning. There is no policy to configure and no category tree to design first.
Feature comparison
| Feature | TaxTidy | Expensify |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | First 25 scans free, no card | Submit — unlimited receipt scanning |
| Photograph receipts from your phone | ✓ | ✓ |
| Expenses placed on Schedule C lines | ✓ | – |
| A score showing what proof is missing | ✓ | – |
| Mileage tracking | Free mileage calculator on the site | ✓ |
| Approval workflows for a team | Not included — TaxTidy is built for one filer | ✓ |
| Corporate card feeds and reconciliation | Not included | ✓ |
| AI assistant for your tax questions | Fin, reading your own expenses | AI-assisted support chat |
| Tax report with receipt images attached | Full-size image beside each expense (Pro) | Expense reports in corporate format |
| Quarterly tax estimates | CPA plan | – |
| How it is priced | One flat price, no per-seat charge | Per member, per month |
Pricing
TaxTidy
- TaxTidy Free$0 — first 25 scans
- TaxTidy Pro$12.99/month ($99.99/yr)
- TaxTidy CPA$19.99/month ($179.99/yr)
Expensify
- Expensify Submit$0 — free, unlimited scanning
- Expensify Collect$5/member/month
- Expensify Control$9/active member/month and up
Expensify pricing is taken from its published plans and can change. Check their site for today's rate.
Choose TaxTidy if
Choose TaxTidy if you are the whole company. No one approves your expenses, no one reimburses you, and the only audience for your records is the IRS. What you need is not a report that moves through a chain of people, but a defensible Schedule C with the paper still attached to it, and that is the entire job TaxTidy does.
What Expensify does well
- The free Submit plan is genuinely free rather than a trial, and it now includes unlimited receipt scanning, mileage tracking and expense reports for an individual.
- Approval workflows are the heart of the product. Submission, review and reimbursement run end to end, which matters the moment there is someone you have to answer to.
- Mileage tracking, chat on every expense, and corporate card management are built in, with card feeds and reconciliation on the paid tiers.
- It scales as a team tool — Collect is $5 per member a month, and Control adds tighter policy controls for larger groups, with discounts for annual commitments.
Choose Expensify if
Choose Expensify if your expenses have to travel through somebody else — you employ people, you bill costs to a client or a finance team, or you carry company cards that need reconciling. It is also a sensible free receipt vault for an individual, since the Submit plan scans without limit and costs nothing. It is not aiming at Schedule C or at audit documentation for a sole proprietor; that is simply a different product.
The bottom line
Expensify is a team’s expense system. TaxTidy is a solo filer’s evidence system. If nobody is approving your expenses and the only reader of your records is the IRS, the work that matters is getting each receipt onto the right tax line with its image attached and knowing where the gaps are. That is the whole of what TaxTidy does, and your first 25 scans cost nothing.
Frequently asked questions
Is TaxTidy a better fit than Expensify for a freelancer?
It depends on what you need from it. Expensify is built for expenses that move through an approval chain, and its free plan is a capable receipt vault. TaxTidy is built for the sole proprietor: expenses are placed on IRS Schedule C lines, scored for whether they have proof behind them, and printed into a report with the receipt images attached. If nobody approves your spending and your records exist for a tax return, TaxTidy is aimed squarely at you.
Does Expensify sort expenses for a tax return?
Expensify categorises expenses by type for expense reporting, and its published plans do not describe mapping them to IRS Schedule C lines or producing Schedule C output. TaxTidy assigns each expense to a specific line — Line 22 for supplies, Line 24b for deductible meals — and carries that line through to the CSV export and the PDF report.
Expensify has a free plan. Why pay for TaxTidy?
Expensify Submit is free and scans without limit, so if all you want is a place to keep receipt images it is a fair choice. TaxTidy earns its price on what happens after the scan: the Schedule C line, the Audit Readiness Score that shows what is missing, the report with the receipt image sitting beside the expense, and Fin answering questions about your own data. Your first 25 scans on TaxTidy are free too, so you can compare the output rather than the promise.
Can I move my Expensify data into TaxTidy?
Yes. Export your expenses from Expensify as a CSV and import it into TaxTidy on Pro or above. TaxTidy reads the rows, categorises each one against a Schedule C line, and matches them against receipts you have already scanned. Anything without an image attached shows up as a gap in your Audit Readiness Score.
TaxTidy provides expense organization tools based on the most current US tax law available to it. TaxTidy is not a CPA, Enrolled Agent, or licensed tax professional. All categorizations, deductions, and tax calculations are estimates. Please verify all data for accuracy and consult a certified tax professional before filing.
Start with your first 25 scans free
Photograph a receipt and watch it land on the right Schedule C line, with an Audit Readiness Score that shows you exactly what is still missing. No credit card.
Get started free